White-collar vs blue-collar jobs—which is the lesser of the two evils? Over the years, white-collar jobs have been hailed as the ultimate pathway to money and success, with blue-collar work being designated as the low-investment, low-return alternative. In 2025, 55% of Americans are now regretting their white-collar jobs and considering a shift to blue-collar roles. This white-collar pivot is unsurprising—many GenZers are already moving away from chasing college degrees and pursuing blue-collar work instead.
A greater number of workers are shifting away from corporate life and its many restrictions, after witnessing the many roadblocks that lie ahead in their respective industries. Many workers are considering switching to manual jobs where their pay is steady and the jobs more secure, however, despite assumptions that blue-collar work is safer, technology is making its way to affect these jobs as well. AGI affects all job classes, and there is fear among workers across the board.
Should white-collar workers give up an switch to blue-collar jobs? Making a shift may be harder than you thing. (Image: Freepik)
White-Collar vs Blue-Collar Jobs—Is One Safer to Pursue than the Other?
White-collar jobs refer to office-based roles and corporate setups, where work typically involves college degrees and formal attire, even though both have been filtered out from many roles. White-collar jobs refer to more labor-intensive manual work that doesn’t require higher education but often necessitates technical certifications of a different kind.
White-collar jobs in tech, law, management, finance, marketing, and other similar fields have largely been applauded as the best pathway toward wealth and prosperity, although these roles typically require more early investments in education. There are often better benefits offered with these roles, with long-term career considerations built into each position.
Blue-collar jobs or trade-based roles in construction, production, maintenance, transportation, and other similar roles, don’t typically require as much of an early investment to get started, but they were previously thought to hold less-successful prospects as well.
In 2025, it appears the narrative is shifting.
Why Is White-Collar Work Losing Its Appeal?
The white-collar job industry, which has never been particularly charming, was lauded as the best way to grow economically. This still remains the case, but there are fewer and fewer opportunities on offer. In 2025, companies have been firing workers without inhibition, making their organization “leaner” for strategic gains. The layoffs have been extremely brutal, coming for workers at private organizations and federal roles in equal measure.
The trend of layoffs wasn’t enough to cause this white-collar pivot all on its own. The problem gets worse when you consider that employers are not hiring either, choosing to preserve their funds for other investments in AI and associated technology. The shifting economic conditions and fear of tariffs have also encouraged organizations to halt major investments or expansions with the goal of waiting it out until stability returns to their industry.
The white-collar hiring slowdown has been extremely difficult for job seekers to witness. To make matters worse, many aspiring candidates are being presented with ghost jobs or fake job postings, while others who finally secure an interview are confronted by dysfunctional AI tools that don’t offer them a real shot at the job.
Career Progression Is A Myth for Many Workers
Layoffs and restrictive hiring aren’t the only challenges workers face. Many millennials who have spent years building their careers have found themselves stagnating. Employers are no longer investing in their careers or offering promises of internal promotions, forcing workers to hop from job to job in search of growth. Frequent job hoppers are further penalized, facing criticism from employers for not staying “loyal” to the organization’s goals.
Senior workers are now staying employed for longer, either due to their own desire to work or due to retirement benefits being pulled further out of their reach. This has caused a block at the top as well, with no room for younger workers to get promotions to better executive roles.
Things are considerably worse for Gen Z. Employers continue to criticize the section of the population and assign blame to these workers for not being good enough for the “professional” workspace and for demanding too much flexibility. Many employers are holding off from hiring Gen Z, choosing to invest in AI instead of in their growth.
Office Workers Seek Hands-on Jobs Instead of Corporate Glory
A survey by TRADESAFE that spoke to 1,000 office workers across the US found that 55% of Americans are considering leaving their white-collar jobs for blue-collar roles. The desire among workers to switch to manual jobs was most prominent among workers in tech, human resources, and health care and it was also higher among Gen Z participants. The cause for this disillusionment with white-collar work was being led by the threat of AI and the effects of burnout experienced in their current career paths.
This desire among office workers to seek hands-on jobs was not uncommon among old workers either. White-collar jobs are notorious for writing off older workers as being outdated, which makes it harder for job hunters from this category to find work. Employers in white-collar industries are not hiring, but they are especially against hiring older employees who will want higher pay as compensation for their experience. These workers are frequently accused of not being up-to-date with the latest AI tools or trends, making them a poor investment.
These older workers aren’t necessarily in a position to take on heavy manual labor either, but many are making their way towards skill-based work or positions in the transportation or manufacturing industry. While some are relying on blue-collar work as a side hustle, others are making a full-time switch to blue-collar work.
White-Collar vs Blue-Collar Jobs—Who Comes Out on Top?
Office workers may be seeking hands-on jobs, but is the situation on the ground truly a better alternative for them? Not necessarily. If workers are switching to manual jobs due to their exhaustion with AI coming for their jobs, there is an equal threat of replacement due to automation among many blue-collar jobs. Many of the layoffs that have occurred this year have occurred at factories and warehouses, where unions are doing their best to keep automation efforts at bay.
In a recent report by Forbes, it was made clear that artificial general intelligence (AGI) was a threat to both white-collar and blue-collar jobs. Currently, artificial intelligence is challenging white-collar roles due to its capability to “think” and outperform its human counterparts in terms of speed and efficiency. Over time, the integration of this same AI in robotics will succeed in simplifying many blue-collar roles as well.
AGI affects all job classes, even if the nature of its effects isn’t clear just yet. The impact on blue-collar work might just be slower to emerge.
Consider the Lower Job Satisfaction Levels Among Blue-Collar Workers
Workers who are considering switching to blue-collar work should also be prepared for manual work. As much as blue-collar work appears to be more charming, respectable, and freeing on the surface, the work is also considerably more grueling than sitting at a desk from 9 to 5. Blue-collar jobs can be tiring, come with greater safety risks, and are also harder to do in a restricted manner.
A study by the Pew Research Center found that blue-collar workers are markedly less satisfied with their jobs compared to other workers, and they often feel less respected and less attached to their jobs. Compared to other workers, a slightly larger number of blue-collar workers felt their pay was insufficient because it did not keep up with the cost-of-living increases and was not enough compensation for the amount of work they did.
The White-Collar Pivot to Blue-Collar Work Needs to Be Planned Carefully
There is something quite admirable and honest about blue-collar work and the workers who perform these jobs, so we understand why white-collar workers might be considering switching to blue-collar jobs. However, when considering white-collar vs blue-collar jobs, workers need to carefully evaluate which is personally better for them. Both come with their own share of challenges and roadblocks that are unlikely to disappear overnight.
White-collar workers should not underestimate the difficulties of abruptly switching to blue-collar work and need to develop their skills before they can consider making a career in a new industry. Flooding the blue-collar industry with untrained labor is not an ideal solution.
Many white-collar workers are exploring entrepreneurship as a part of their long-term career strategy, which might make for a better application of existing college degrees and skill sets rather than shifting industries. Upskilling to keep up with AI and other technological trends also might be more beneficial to safeguard one’s career instead of giving it up entirely. Explore your options patiently and you might find a strategy that suits you best.
Subscribe to The HR Digest for more insights into how the landscape of work and employment is evolving right now.