The post-COVID workplace has evolved beyond our imagination. And yet, it raises a pressing question among employees: Can your employer force you to return to the office? With return-to-office (RTO) mandates becoming commonplace, it’s important to understand your rights and options. Companies like Amazon, JP Morgan & Chase, Dell, and even the U.S. Federal Government have ordered employees back to the office, prompting significant pushback from employees and widespread resignations. It will be a matter of time until companies of all sizes enforce a full-time onsite workweek. To help you cope with RTO mandates, we’ve explored the legalities, employee rights, and practical steps you can take if your employer forces you to return to the office.
The rise of return-to-office (RTO) mandates
A 2024 survey by ResumeBuilder noted that 90% of executives plan to implement RTO policies by the end of 2025, citing benefits such as improved collaboration and company culture. Yet, these RTO mandates have sparked employee pushback, significant dissatisfaction, and even public backlash.
Learn about full-time in-office policies, employee resistance, and impacts on collaboration, productivity, and workforce flexibility.
Nearly 70% of remote work prefer to seek new jobs rather than return of the office. In the post-COVID world, employees value flexibility from reduced commuting costs and better work-life balance. So, what happens when your employer demands a forced return to the office?
Can employers legally end remote work?
Yes. Employers can require employees to return to the office. Here’s why:
At-will employment: In the U.S., most employees work under “at-will” employment. This means that employers can change job conditions, including work location, without prior notice. Unless your employment contract explicitly guarantees remote work, employers can mandate in-person work.
Contractual agreements: If your employment contract specifies remote work as a condition of employment, mandating you back to the office could breach that agreement. However, such contracts are rare, and job descriptions or offer letters don’t typically count as binding contracts.
Business needs: Employers can justify RTO mandates if they believe in-person work improves collaboration, productivity, or company culture. American courts generally uphold an employer’s right to set workplace policies unless they violate specific laws.
Employee rights in remote work disputes
There are exceptions where employees may have leverage. Employers may hold significant power, however, employees have certain rights that can protect them from RTO mandates. Below are a few key considerations:
Disability accommodations
Under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), employers must provide reasonable accommodations for employees with disabilities. If returning to the office poses significant challenges due to medical conditions, you may request to continue working remotely. Employers must engage in an “interactive process” to address your needs, although they can deny accommodation requests if they cause “undue hardship.”
For instance, an employee with a chronic illness that increases Covid-19 risks could argue that remote work is a reasonable accommodation.
Discrimination protections
RTO policies must not discriminate based on protected characteristics like race, gender, age or disability. For instance, if only certain groups are required to return while others can work remotely, this could violate anti-discrimination laws.
Family status accommodations
Employers must also look into accommodations unless they cause significant hardship.
Workplace safety
Under the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), employers must provide a safe workplace. If you believe the office environment is unsafe, you can raise concerns. However, refusing to return solely due to general discomfort with long commute or better work-life balance may not be legally protected.
Constructive dismissal
In cases where remote work was a core part of your role (e.g., you were hired as a full-time remote employee), mandating a return could be considered “constructive dismissal.” This occurs when an employer makes significant changes to your job, effectively forcing you to resign. In Ontario, this could entitle you to severance pay, potentially up to 24 months.
What to do if your employer demands a return to the office?
Facing a forced return to the office can feel overwhelming, but you have options. Here’s a step-by-step guide:
Review your employment contract: Check your employment agreement for any clauses about work location. If remote work was explicitly promised, you may have grounds to negotiate or challenge the mandate.
Document: Keep records of communications about the RTO policy, including emails, memos, or verbal agreements. This can support your case if you pursue legal action.
Make a flexible working request: For instance, the UK grants employees the legal right to request flexible working arrangements, including remote or hybrid schedules. Even in the U.S., proposing a hybrid model can open a dialogue.
Negotiate with your employer: Approach your employer calmly and professionally. Highlight how remote work benefits the company, such as increased productivity or reduced overhead costs. Suggest compromises, like a hybrid schedule or additional benefits to offset commuting costs.
Consider your leverage: If you’re in a high-demand role or industry, you may have more negotiating power. Some employees have successfully secured remote work by emphasizing their value to the company.
Explore new opportunities: If your employer won’t budge, consider looking for remote-friendly jobs. Platforms like FlexJobs list reputable companies offering 100% remote roles in fields like IT, healthcare, and education.
Employer and employee needs
Return-to-office mandates highlight a broader tension between employer priorities and employee preferences. Employers argue that in-person work fosters collaboration and strengthens culture, while employees value the flexibility and cost savings of remote work. A 2024 FlexJobs report found that 57% of remote workers would quit if forced to return to the office, signaling potential turnover risks for rigid employers.
Hybrid models are emerging as a compromise, with many companies requiring two to four days in the office per week. This approach aims to balance collaboration with flexibility, but it requires clear communication and fair implementation to succeed.
FAQs About Return-to-Office Mandates
Q: Can my employer force me to return to the office if I was hired as a remote worker?
A: If your contract explicitly states remote work as a condition, forcing you back could breach the agreement. However, without a binding contract, employers can change work locations, especially in at-will employment states. Consult a lawyer to review your contract.
Q: What are my remote work legal rights?
A: Your rights depend on local laws, contracts, and specific circumstances. You may be protected under disability or anti-discrimination laws, or you could request accommodations for family responsibilities. Always document communications and seek legal advice.
Q: Can I refuse to return to the office due to safety concerns?
A: You can refuse if the workplace poses a specific, documented safety risk (e.g., non-compliance with health guidelines). General concerns about commuting or crowds are less likely to be protected. Check OSHA guidelines or local health and safety laws.
Q: What options do I have if my employer ends remote work?
A: You can negotiate for a hybrid schedule, request accommodations, or seek legal advice. If the mandate is non-negotiable, consider looking for remote-friendly jobs. Platforms like FlexJobs can help.
Q: Can I be fired for refusing to return to the office?
A: Yes, in at-will employment, employers can terminate you for refusing to comply with an RTO mandate, unless it violates discrimination laws, safety regulations, or a contract. Refusal could also qualify you for unemployment benefits in some cases.
Know your rights
Return-to-office mandates are reshaping workplaces, but employees aren’t powerless. By understanding your remote work rights, reviewing contracts, and negotiating strategically, you can advocate for flexibility. If your employer demands a forced return to the office, weigh your options carefully—whether that’s negotiating, seeking legal advice, or exploring new remote opportunities.
Have you faced a return-to-office mandate? Share your experience in the comments or contact an employment lawyer for personalized guidance. The workplace is evolving, and your voice matters.
Subscribe to The HR Digest for the latest HR news and employment updates.