In this Q&A, our resident HR advisor Jane Harper guides employees on how to navigate the tricky waters of discussing salary with colleagues. She shares practical tips on talking about pay at work, maintaining professionalism, and fostering salary transparency without creating workplace gossip about salary. From knowing your rights to providing context and using conversations to advocate for fair compensation, Jane’s advice helps employees approach colleague salary discussions with confidence, ensuring pay equity at work while keeping workplace relationships intact.
A reader writes:
Dear Jane,
Some of my colleagues have started talking about how much they earn, and one even asked me to share my salary. I’ve always been told that talking about pay at work is risky, but I also know salary transparency is becoming more common. I don’t want to come across as unfriendly or secretive, but I also don’t want workplace gossip about salary to spread. How should I handle discussing salary with colleagues?
How to Talk About Salary at Work With Colleagues
You’re not alone in feeling this way. Conversations about salary can feel awkward, but with the rise of salary transparency and calls for pay equity at work, knowing how to handle colleague salary discussions professionally is essential. Let’s break it down.
In today’s workplace, employees are more informed than ever. Online salary platforms, market benchmarks, and new laws supporting compensation disclosure mean that talking about pay at work isn’t as taboo as it used to be. For many, these conversations help ensure fairness, promote pay equity at work, and even guide career decisions.
That said, workplace salary conversations can backfire if handled poorly. Without context, numbers can lead to misunderstandings, resentment, or even office gossip.
How to Approach Discussing Salary With Colleagues
Here are practical strategies to handle salary discussions tactfully:
- Know your rights and policies
Many regions legally protect your right to talk about salary. At the same time, check company policies. Some workplaces encourage transparency; others expect discretion. - Decide what to share
You’re not obligated to reveal your exact pay. Sharing a range (“I’m in the $60k–$65k band”) is often enough to contribute meaningfully to the conversation. - Provide context
Differences in tenure, responsibilities, or skills often explain pay variations. If you share, clarify the context so comparisons are fair. - Keep it constructive, not gossipy
Avoid framing salary conversations as “Who earns more?” Instead, focus on compensation transparency, understanding market rates, or exploring equity concerns. - Leverage the conversation for self-advocacy
If you discover you may be underpaid, use the insight to speak with HR or your manager. For example: “I’ve reviewed internal pay bands and market data; I’d like to discuss adjusting my compensation.”
Between colleagues:
A: “Do you mind sharing roughly where your salary falls? I’m trying to gauge fairness.”
B: “I’m happy to give a range. I’m in $60k–$65k, but I also have five years of experience in this role, which may explain the difference.”
Employee to manager:
“Based on market benchmarks and internal pay bands, I’d like to discuss aligning my compensation with my responsibilities.”
These examples show how to be transparent without oversharing or fostering workplace gossip about salary.
HR and Leader Guidance
HR leaders can reduce conflict by promoting salary transparency and creating clear guidelines for compensation disclosure:
- Publish pay bands and promotion criteria.
- Train managers to handle salary conversations respectfully.
- Encourage professional, constructive workplace salary conversations.
Common Pitfalls
- Comparing numbers without context.
- Letting gossip drive assumptions about fairness.
- Assuming similar titles always mean similar pay.
Avoiding these pitfalls keeps discussions professional and reduces tension.
Talking about pay at work isn’t inherently risky, but it must be handled thoughtfully. Respect boundaries, provide context, focus on fairness, and use discussions to empower your career rather than fuel office gossip. With tact, colleague salary discussions can promote transparency, equity, and trust.
Subscribe to The HR Digest for more insights on workplace trends, layoffs, and what to expect with the advent of AI.